War of the Worlds
Bruce and I went to see War of the Worlds yesterday afternoon. It's hard to describe how I felt about this film. I didn't really like it. I wouldn't watch it again. Nonetheless, it was quite unsettling. Which, I suppose, means it was an effective film.
Parts of it were quite frightening, even though it's not a horror film. But they weren't frightening in that cathartic horror film kind of way. More in just a really unsettling kind of way. Parts of it were unnecessarily grotesque, and those parts don't even make sense. If there was a purpose to them, it was never explained. Not unsatisfactorily explained. Just not explained at all. I have to believe they were in there simply for the gross-out factor. Which is fine, but as one who enjoys good horror, I prefer an actual reason for the gross-out. I suppose this is why I don't care for pure hack-and-slash horror.
Continue only if you don't mind spoilers.
The ending was preposterously simplistic. Oh look, the entire family survived! Even after the son was caught on the forefront of a massive alien attack, somehow he managed to not only survive but find his way up to his grandparents' house in Boston. Before his father and sister get there. They never explained how that happened. It just did.
The only good old human ingenuity portrayed in this film was in survival. I guess that's fine, but I would have preferred a little more of "the humans figure out a way to kill aliens" (aside from a couple of grenades up the gullet, which is not a particularly good long-term plan). In the end, the aliens just die. If any character in the movie actually figures out what killed them, we sure don't know about it. The narrator tells the audience that it was the bacteria that done them in, but it all seems quite deus ex machina-like. I understand in the original that it is the bacteria, but the scientists figure that out after it starts occurring and use it to their advantage. Not so here.
However, this movie does go to show something I've always believed. Despite the fact that the aliens attack Tokyo and the Ukraine pretty much simultaneously, they attack New York before Boston. I assume this is the case, because people in Boston have power and seem to have actually survived without having to run. Which, I mean, of course. Even the aliens don't care that much about Boston. ;^)
Although as I write that sentence, one thing occurs to me. This would mean that the Yankees are destroyed, but the Red Sox survive. Oh no! It is a horror film after all!
Comments
Spoiler? For a movie that's been remade two or three times, from probably the world's most famous radio show, and all those from a popular science fiction novel? Heck, the whole world knows the ending. You guys win.
Posted by: hnumpah | July 11, 2005 10:21 PM
Well, okay, sure, but the details have changed. I think. I never saw the original or heard the radio broadcast. But I'm pretty sure they've changed the details, even if the main plot is consistent.
Posted by: Lesley | July 12, 2005 09:39 AM
hmmm... 'you guys,win' hnumpah? are you one of those north american grays i'm always hearing about on ufo files?
Posted by: Mom | July 12, 2005 12:58 PM
((shaking both heads 'No'))
Posted by: hnumpah | July 13, 2005 01:35 PM
lol.... well clearly you're not, cuz n. american grays only have one head. :)
Posted by: Mom | July 13, 2005 02:07 PM